![](https://i0.wp.com/static01.nyt.com/images/2023/12/14/multimedia/14dc-rudy-qgtj/14dc-rudy-qgtj-facebookJumbo.jpg?ssl=1)
A lawyer for 2 former Georgia election staff advised members of a jury in federal court docket on Thursday that they need to ship a message in contemplating how a lot Rudolph W. Giuliani ought to should pay for spreading defamatory lies about them as a part of his effort three years in the past to maintain President Donald J. Trump in workplace.
“Ship it to Mr. Giuliani,” the lawyer, Michael J. Gottlieb, stated in his closing argument. “Ship it to some other highly effective determine with a platform and an viewers who’s contemplating whether or not they may take the prospect to hunt revenue and fame by assassinating the ethical character of peculiar folks.”
The election staff, Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss, who have been counting ballots at State Farm Enviornment in Fulton County, Ga., on Nov. 3, 2020, are asking for at the very least $24 million every from Mr. Giuliani for baselessly accusing them of dishonest Mr. Trump out of votes and broadcasting that deceive hundreds of thousands of followers on social media.
Choose Beryl A. Howell of the Federal District Court docket in Washington has already discovered that Mr. Giuliani, who served as Mr. Trump’s private lawyer and helped lead the hassle to overturn the 2020 election end result, defamed the ladies. The jury within the civil trial is barely being requested to find out what damages Mr. Giuliani ought to pay. The jurors adjourned on Thursday afternoon and have been set to choose up their deliberations on Friday.
In a last-minute choice, Mr. Giuliani determined to not testify as deliberate on Thursday. His lawyer and Choose Howell had expressed considerations for days that Mr. Giuliani would repeat his unfounded claims of election fraud from the stand, as he did on Monday exterior the courthouse when he attacked Ms. Freeman and Ms. Moss once more.
Mr. Giuliani’s lawyer, Joseph Sibley IV, additionally requested the jury to ship a message, by not touchdown on a “catastrophic” greenback determine.
“I’m asking you to be affordable and be simply,” Mr. Sibley stated.
Mr. Sibley stated that Mr. Giuliani has admitted that he was improper, however that the torrent of abuse directed at Ms. Freeman and Ms. Moss after his statements about them was not solely his fault.
Mr. Sibley argued that Mr. Giuliani didn’t himself say all the horrible and racist issues or encourage violence towards the ladies, and that no amount of cash might realistically restore the ladies’s reputations within the eyes of the individuals who consider the lies. Mr. Giuliani, he stated, is aware of that defamation is improper, as a result of he believes he has been defamed by President Biden.
Mr. Sibley requested jurors to recollect Mr. Giuliani by the fame he had 20 years in the past, after serving as mayor of New York Metropolis and as a federal prosecutor who took down the mob.
“Rudy Giuliani shouldn’t be outlined by what’s occurred in current occasions,” Mr. Sibley stated. “It is a man who did nice issues.”
Throughout the trial, Ms. Freeman and Ms. Moss, who’re mom and daughter, delivered emotional testimony about how the falsehoods unfold by Mr. Giuliani ruined their lives.
They advised the jury they’d obtained a whole bunch of threatening and racist messages from individuals who believed Mr. Giuliani’s assertion, inflicting them to lose their livelihoods, transfer out of their houses and endure emotional misery.