Greek’s financial rebound in (painful) context

Keep knowledgeable with free updates

Merely signal as much as the World Financial system myFT Digest — delivered on to your inbox.

It’s time to take a look at Greece’s sturdy post-pandemic financial restoration in a historic context. Tl;dr: the nation is certainly among the many finest current performers within the eurozone, nevertheless it has additionally change into the poorest.

Final week, ranking company S&P was the newest to sing the nation’s well-deserved reward because it revised the nation’s outlook to “constructive”. This was on the again of Greek authorities enterprise “a broad ranging structural reform agenda and tackling long-standing bottlenecks” boosting progress above the eurozone common and leading to a falling debt-to-GDP ratio.

The constructive outlook displays our expectation that the tight fiscal regime will proceed to spur a discount within the authorities debt ratio, whereas progress ought to proceed to outperform that of Greece’s eurozone friends.

Certainly, new information printed by Eurostat on Monday confirmed that Greek authorities debt relative to GDP fell by 10.8 share factors to 162 per cent in 2023.

The Greek financial system grew by 2 per cent in 2023, outshining the 0.3 per cent contraction in Germany. Since 2019, earlier than the pandemic, the nation has grown at almost double the eurozone’s fee. Final week the IMF mentioned the Greek financial system will develop by 2 per cent once more this yr, and proceed to outperform the foreign money union’s common progress fee for the following two years.

Robust tourism numbers — which go hand in hand with enchancment within the labour market and the restoration in consumption — are serving to. So too are structural reforms aimed toward eradicating obstacles to progress, resembling growing digital entry to public companies, accelerating judicial selections, and bettering transparency and public funds.

As BNP Paribas economist Guillaume Derrien advised FTAV:

Renewed political stability and sharp fiscal consolidation is making Greece a way more engaging nation for funding than prior to now.

Nonetheless . . .

The most recent rebound has solely simply barely lifted Greek dwelling requirements relative to the EU common within the final couple of years — and never sufficient to raise them from their place because the poorest folks within the eurozone.

It is a comparatively new factor for Greece, as per-capita GDP was much like that of the EU common till 2009. Since then, 10 nations have seen dwelling requirements rise above these in Greece, leaving it the second poorest within the EU after Bulgaria, and the poorest within the frequent foreign money bloc

With the hole with Bulgaria narrowing sharply, it’s not unreasonable to count on that Greece will quickly change into the EU’s poorest nation.

How do these reverse tales of sturdy rebound and poverty reconcile?

The reply lies within the aftermath of the monetary disaster and the austerity that adopted the 2010 disaster. Greek spending was minimize and taxes elevated to safe a bailout from the IMF and the EU, squeezing companies and households and demolishing the financial system. The extent of the financial harm was distinctive for peacetime.

The Greek financial system shrank by almost 30 per cent peak-to-through. In 2016, client spending was down 24 per cent from 2007, authorities spending was down 20 per cent and funding plummeted by 65 per cent. Over the identical interval, manufacturing exercise almost halved, retail commerce {and professional} exercise shrank by almost one-third. Unemployment shot to an all-time excessive of almost 30 per cent.

Because of this, the Greek financial system is at this time about 19 per cent smaller than in 2007 — regardless of the nation’s sturdy post-pandemic rebound — whereas the EU financial system as a complete has risen by 17 per cent.

The financial hit is almost unprecedented in fashionable instances, solely similar to the US Nice Melancholy within the Nineteen Thirties, notes George Lagarias chief economist at Mazars Wealth Administration.

Actual wages have been steadily declining till 2022, the newest obtainable within the OECD database, and are down 30 per cent from their pre-financial disaster ranges, leaving the nation with one of many lowest common salaries amongst developed economies.

The development sector — an necessary driver of progress earlier than the disaster — has been almost worn out. Residential funding, which represented over 10 per cent of GDP on the peak of the 2008 bubble, has since plunged to 2 per cent of GDP, the bottom share amongst eurozone nations. As BNP’s Derrien says:

Greece has now a much less unbalanced financial growth mannequin — which is a constructive — however the drop in building exercise has but to be totally rebalanced by the enlargement in new sectors.

There are additionally issues in regards to the nation’s longer-term financial outlook.

Lagarias argues that progress with restricted leverage — which is the case of Greece — will stay sluggish, and predicts that it’s going to take a few years of “persistent reforms” for Greece to get again to the place it was in 2007. Low funding and sluggish productiveness additionally proceed to hamstring Greece’s financial potential, in response to Derrien.

In its newest nation report, the IMF additionally talked about local weather change as a hazard — as 90 per cent of the nation’s tourism infrastructure and 80 per cent of commercial actions are in areas uncovered to excessive local weather dangers — and the more and more dour demographics.

Greek births fell to a nine-decade low in 2022, aggravating the nation’s ageing and shrinking inhabitants as many younger folks depart the nation yearly.

Total, Greece’s financial rebound ought to be celebrated, nevertheless it must be seen within the context of a outstanding financial disaster that has left it in a gap which may take a technology to climb out of.