No, Microsoft, Home windows 11’s Begin menu is not a ‘sport changer’

Microsoft is going through an issue. Years after launching Home windows 11, prospects merely favor Home windows 10 extra. So the Home windows advertising and marketing staff is making an attempt every part they will emigrate customers to Home windows 11 — and a latest video reveals how they’re, nicely, failing.

Look, we get it: transitioning to an unfamiliar manner of doing issues is difficult. And in case you’re snug with even an inefficient manner of navigating about (sorry, command-line Linux customers) you’re going to keep it up. However promoting the Home windows 11 with a Begin menu that’s a “game-changer”? Whew. No.

“Begin Recent With out Stating Over” is Microsoft’s swing at simply this. The video (embedded beneath) is nicely, oh man.

“This new Begin menu is a game-changer,” a assured younger feminine voice intones. “I can discover precisely what I want very quickly.”

Let’s cease right here for a second. By default, Home windows 10 places apps to the aspect of its Begin menu, with a navigable listing of apps that may be scrolled up and down. In Home windows 11, your apps could seem within the mishmash of apps proven off within the Begin menu, however not in case you not too long ago put in them. Then it’s important to squint, click on the “all apps” button and make your manner down by to that listing.

So, if you recognize what you’re doing? Positive. In any other case, no. The one game-changer here’s a 30-second timeout whilst you search out what you’re searching for.

“This new File Explorer retains me completely organized,” the narrator continues. “It makes it really easy to search out all my recordsdata.”

To me, File Explorer in Home windows 10 and Home windows 11 doesn’t differ by that a lot — with a few ache factors that Microsoft doesn’t handle on this video. Specifically, the “present extra choices” right-click choice that makes File Explorer basically provide a double menu, and the hieroglyphic copy/paste/rename icons that Microsoft is fortunately attaching labels to in a latest Home windows 11 take a look at construct.

However discovering recordsdata isn’t terrific, both. As commenters level out, the tile interface of Home windows 10 does make it simpler to floor fast hyperlinks and shortcuts arguably higher than the “Really helpful” file listing in Home windows 11. I’m simply ready for the day the place Microsoft indexes my SSD quick and nicely sufficient that I don’t have to attend dozens of seconds for it to search out particular recordsdata, in both Home windows 10 or 11.

Statcounter

The ultimate level that the video makes — that Home windows Defender simply protects your PC — is true, and has been for years.

“Home windows 11 simply makes the on a regular basis, simpler,” the video concludes.

It actually doesn’t. Home windows 11 does provide quite a bit, particularly in case you’re desperate to see what AI-powered options like Automated Tremendous Decision will provide. However even then, Microsoft has injected Copilot into Home windows 10. Home windows 11 now has occasional characteristic “advertisements,” too. However stripping Home windows 10 options away just like the tiled interface and adjustable taskbar makes probably the most frequently-used options of Home windows really feel considerably alien to a Home windows 10 consumer.

Sadly, Home windows 10 assist ends in 2025 in about eighteen months’ time. That offers Microsoft’s staff many extra months to try to persuade Home windows 10 customers to modify. You’ll must do it by then for safety causes anyway, as a result of staying on a useless working system is insanity.